#3 pick 12 team roto, who do I take?

[JDAWG5]

OK, this is my first ever fantasy baseball draft, and I want to make sure I don't mess it up.

I'm assuming that Pujols will go #1.

The guy picking 2nd is either taking Votto or Hanley.

If Hanley is there I will take him because ss is really thin this year, however if the guy in front of me takes Hanley, who should I pick?

Miguel Cabrera kind of scares me with with his recent DUI.

Do I take Tulo because as I already stated ss is thin?

Thanks in advance

[raiders_umpire]

Mcab if he is there

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd take Hanley if he is left first, but I expect he will be taken. After that, it's Miggy all the way IMO.

[HOOTIE]

I'd take Hanley if he is left first, but I expect he will be taken. After that, it's Miggy all the way IMO.

[oldmanbean]

hate to wimp out, but I would go Ramirez/Miggy.

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=423298

[theplayer11]

If you go Tulo at #3, you will still be able to snag Howard/Fielder at #22. So, you have an elite player at very thin position and still have a power 1st baseman.
1B is deep, no need to draft 2 in 1st 2 rounds. I always look at it as how my team is built over the first 2-3 picks, not just player A vs player B(Tulo vs Miggy).
I'm actually surprised everyone has responded with Miggy.(especially with his recent troubles).

edit:above is assuming Hanley is gone at #2

[hmfc1874]

If you go Tulo at #3, you will still be able to snag Howard/Fielder at #22. So, you have an elite player at very thin position and still have a power 1st baseman.
1B is deep, no need to draft 2 in 1st 2 rounds. I always look at it as how my team is built over the first 2-3 picks, not just player A vs player B(Tulo vs Miggy).
I'm actually surprised everyone has responded with Miggy.(especially with his recent troubles).

edit:above is assuming Hanley is gone at #2

There's a fair difference between Miggy and Howard/Fielder really, and Tulo's ranking is based on being hotter than the sun for 1 month last year - he hit almost half his homers in September whereas Miggy has put up excellent numbers for years now.

[kidsilk]

Gotta go with Hanley then Miggy. Don't worry about his DUI! Do not and I repeat do not take Tulo that high. He is not worth it. He is good but unproven still and injury prone. Miggy is too good to pass up. I would rather take Votto, Braun, CarGo over Tulo. But that is just my opinion.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=423374

[down.by.law]

Hanley or Cabrera. Don't sweat the DUI. I am also in the school of thought of getting OF and 1B later in the draft. Good luck!