Rollins/Snider for Bucholz/W. Myers in a Dynasty? WHIR

[mktgteach]

Hi,

Rosters aside, which side do you feel has the most overall value?

Side A

Jimmy Rollins and Travis Snider

Side B

Clay Bucholz and Will Myers

FYI, Jimmy Rollins is my starting MI. Aaron Hill would come off my bench and into my MI spot. Snider is on my bench behind Carlos Lee. Bucholz would not be one of my starting 5, as I have Sabatha, Price, Verlander, Oswalt, and Gallardo. Bucholz would provide depth with Hudson, Matusz, B. Myers, and B Morrow.

Your thoughts?

[Johnny Tuttle]

Bird in the hand: I would rather own Buch than Rollins in a dynasty, and you could even win the OF flip, too.

Deal for me. I take it.

[MaudDib]

I think you stay put. I like Snider a lot this year. Not a big fan of Rollins but not really a big fan of Buchholz and I think Rollins could be more of a help to you. Myers has a lot of upside but he is a prospect that has not played much (if any) at AA so there is still a lot of projection with him.

[Seanyfever]

I like to know what I have. Side A seems like best package despite some concerns. I may have fewer than others.

Lend me your voice?
viewtopic.php?t=423288

[MadDog36]

Jimmy Rollins and Travis Snider I'd take this side. You can get one more studly year from Rollins. I don't want using Hill as a MI unless I had too, but he's nice for depth. Yuck if you did the deal that would leave you too thin on both accounts ,yuck.