Stanton for Uggla - better keeper? WHIR

[dooho]

i have 2 OF keepers already in mccutchen and kemp, i'd to be a little more flexible going in to the draft. oh, i should also note that this is the final year of our keeper, so THIS year only.

which is the better final keeper, stanton at $5 or uggla at $10

small note, those won't be the final keeping price. we go into a keeper auction where they are bid on. owner gets to keep at 2/3 bid price or original price, whichever is higher. for example if stanton is is bid to $20, i keep him at $13 (20x2/3).

leave a link. thanks

[skmo2345]

Uggla at 10. There are plenty of OF in the draft, but not as many solid 2B.

[Whalewang]

Give me Uggla also.
If this was long term decision then I'd probably go Stanton but for one year only and ~$5 more I'll take Uggla.

[galante22]

for just next year ill take uggla, 30 hrs out of 2b is always nice


viewtopic.php?t=422932
help with mine

[miketidd44]

I'm lovin Uggla this year. I'd especially keep him since he's a top 2B (thin position) and Stanton is a high risk/high reward OF (J. Upton comes to mind).

Mine? viewtopic.php?t=423025

[silverlionlb]

While I do like the price and upside on Stanton, I think you gotta go with Uggla. Reliable power value at 2B is a nice thing to have that cheap!

If you have the time, I could use any input on my keepers. Good luck! viewtopic.php?t=423031