need to pick 4: utley mauer werth chapman butler scherzer

[jiggs]

I'm in a long term keeper league (H2H 5x5) and can only keep 4 of these players. I currently have them listed in the order that I'm thinking. What do you guys think about Chapman, Butler or Scherzer long term?

Chase Utley
Joe Mauer
Jayson Werth
Aroldis Chapman
Billy Butler
Max Scherzer
John Danks
David Ortiz

[jmlevy]

Personally:
Utley
Mauer
Butler
Chapman/Werth

I think Werth is overvalued and will flop this year only protected by Zimmerman. Go with the upside and long-term potential in Chapman.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=422744

[razzy]

I rank them like this....

Utley
Mauer
Butler
Scherzer

I wouldnt argue with Chapman over Scherzer though

Help? viewtopic.php?t=422750

[HOOTIE]

Utley
Mauer
Butler
Chapman

[Redmond_Square]

C Mauer
1b Butler
2b Utley
SP Chapman

Ditto the rest.

[jiggs]

I came into this thinking Werth was a no-brainer, but after looking into it I agree with you guys. I'm definitely thinking Butler instead of Werth, now just have to decide between Chapman and Scherzer. Being a Tiger's fan complicates this decision...