Dynasty F-Her/? for R. Zimmerman

[bujfan2030]

20 team Dynasty H2H 13cat(OBP, QS, Holds, K/9 instead of SO). We're in the middle of a slow draft. Non-salary, No FAAB. Roster 25 + 5 Minor league slots.
My roster
C-
1B-Aubrey Huff
2B-Brandon Phillips
3B-Ryan Zimmerman
SS-Tsuyoshi Nikiosha
OF-Alex Rios
OF-Brett Gardner
OF-Ryan Raburn
UTil-
SP-Wainwright
SP-Hellickson
SP-Kuroda
RP-Carlos Marmol
RP-
RP-
P-J. Zimmerman
P-
P-
Prospect-Mike Trout
Prospect-Brandon Belt
So I'm looking to replace Wainwright. For Ryan Zimmerman he's willing to offer F-Her and Dominic Brown.
Or F-Her and Multiple picks.(16th,17th round). He's got Mark Reynolds at 3rd. Would you push for For F-Her/Reynolds?
Also getting some offers for Wainwright what's the least you'd accept in return.

[LeftyQB]

Wow...tough one...honestly I don't love your lineup and giving up Zim will hurt. F-Her is a stud and I definitely would think about it. Brown has a ton of upside....if you could get a couple of more bats you should pull the trigger.

Here's mine: viewtopic.php?t=422635

[Redmond_Square]

If you could toss in a meaningless prosepct and acquire both Reynolds and FHernandez I would jump all over it. His BA will be more respectable this year, he's got good lineup protection in Baltimore yes you cannot deny the upgrades they have made, and that was just a flopperoo. I think a BA about 250 will be respectable with his immense power, he might put up a line close to the like Bautista did last year.

[Grounded Polo]

I'd rather keep Zimmerman, Alex Rios as my best bat in a 20 team league is just scary, would rather try to get lucky on starting pitching.

[bujfan2030]

Well for F-Her/Reynolds and a pick he's asking Zimmerman/Phillips or Zimmerman/Rios and a pick to him for Fher/D. Brown
THis just seems way to steep to me. If I'm going to give up my best player just feel like I should get more in return.
Essentially he's a first rounder. Probably going to try to move Phillips or Rios for some pitching.

[MaudDib]

I'd rather keep Zimmerman, Alex Rios as my best bat in a 20 team league is just scary, would rather try to get lucky on starting pitching.

Pitching is deeper this year. Keep the bat.

[mpieco]

I'd rather keep Zimmerman, Alex Rios as my best bat in a 20 team league is just scary, would rather try to get lucky on starting pitching.

Quoted for truth. Rios as a best bat in a 20 team league is VERY scary. You need to sit on this, and just hope to hit some late-round sleepers at pitcher.

[ABA316]

Stand down. You'll have issues with hitting if you do this one. Losing Wainwright hurts but don't compound the problem.

Help viewtopic.php?t=422815