Keeper Question! WHIRG! Pujols or Cano/Hamilton?

[Cypher74]

Hi guys,

H2H Yahoo Points League. We keep 3 with no penalty/draft round.

I currently have Pujols/Lester/Price as my 3 keepers. Pitchers have a slight uptick in value due to the point structure of this league.

I am being offered Cano/Josh Hamilton for Pujols.

This would leave me with Cano/Hamilton/Lester

Which group would you rather start the season with in a keeper league???

Leave a link, I WHIR Guaranteed!

[bloul11]

I generally tend to devalue pitchers as a whole. So I think I would rather have Cano and Hamilton. On the other hand Pujols is really hard to give up. If it was during the season and a team offers you Hamilton an Cano for Pujols you would probably take it. So am saying take it.

thanks for your help with mine.

[Wadderboiz]

#1 2B, Top 3 OF, and a top 5 SP sounds good to me. Price is essentially capped out in that tough division.

[Cypher74]

Pujols is just so consistent, its tough to take guys who have some risk in exchange for him

[HOOTIE]

Give me Cano/Hamilton

[avsfan4ever33]

It is tough to deal Pujols, but you're getting good value back for him. I'd make the deal and go into the draft with a nice set of three keepers.