Hamels vs youk WHIR

[galante22]

5x5 h2h standard scoring, 14 teams, you can keep 5 players for up to 3 years, also future (who you designate prior to the season, has to be rookie etc) anyway this is what my keeper situation looks like

c-carlos santana(future)
1b-youk
ss-tulo
3b-arod
of-cargo
sp-ubaldo

obviously my team is hitter heavy which i dont mind at all, my problem is i have the 14th pick. currently im putting victorino, werth, and cain back into the draft. with the 14th pick(and 15th sicne its snake) i dont think many pitchers will fall to me. im praying cain will as verlander, c.c., kershaw are all in the draft but those 3 probably go in the first 5-7 picks. its looking more and more like i wont get cain and after him i could possibly end up wiht liriano(but he might go earlier too), beckett, scherzer, hughes, colby lewis, danks, etc. if i dont get liriano or cain i think i might go two hitters as i can probably grab a brandon philips and shane victorino over a scherzer or beckett? ive been offered hamels for cain and victorino. do i take the trade and keep hamels over youk and put him back into the draft?

[Elsy]

No, not enough value there IMO. If anyhting I might keep Cain over Youk.

[Surfs up]

I would go with the hitter just about anytime unless it was a top 5 pitcher.In this case Youkilis over Hamels or Cain

[avsfan4ever33]

I'd hold onto Youk and hope for a pitcher to fall to you in the draft.

Help me?

[HOOTIE]

Keep Youkilis and try for Liriano/Scherzer.

[fast dogs]

Youk.
might be suprised by SP that makes its to you, lotta guys going to wait on SP this year

[raiders_umpire]

I would keep Youk, and I see nothing wrong with drafting Liriano as the ace of your staff if he falls to you.