Better group of keepers?

[galante22]

5x5 standard scoring, h2h format, can only keep 5 players for a max of 3 years,also get a futures pick who was designated prior to the season, if oyu never staretd him essentially hes a 6th keeper, what is the better group and who would you keep?

group 1
of-ichiro
of-ethier
sp-tommy hanson
sp-dan haren
sp-wandy
rp-soria
of-adam lind
1b/3b-pablo

group 2
c-mccann
3b-zimmerman
sp-gallardo
of-jason bay
of-tori hunter
dh-vlad
of-colby rasmus
rp-ryan franklin
sp-dickey
sp-jaime garcia


reason i mention so many guys on gorup 2 is the guy who took that team over is keeping some totlly different people then i would lol he admits to not knowing much about fantasy baseball thank god, just wondering whats the better group in your eyes

[brad_fox87]

For group 1: I'd keep Ichiro and Ethier for sure, then Hanson cause I think he'll be an ace this year, then probably Dan Haren, and last I'd take Lind. I think Lind will bounce back more than Pablo, so I'd take Lind over him, and I also don't think you should pay for saves by keeping Soria.

For group 2: Definitely keep Zimmerman, Gallardo, and McCann. Then I'd go with Rasmus, who I think could have a big breakout year, and then I guess Hunter. You at least know what you'll get with him over Vlad or Bay, and again I wouldn't pay for saves with Franklin.

As for which is better, I'd take group 2 because they have the best overall player with Zimmerman, better range of positions with top catcher and 3B, and higher upside with Rasmus and Zimm rather than the aging Ichiro and unpredictable Lind.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=422405

[MaudDib]

group 1
of-ichiro
of-ethier
sp-tommy hanson
sp-dan haren
sp-wandy
rp-soria
of-adam lind
1b/3b-pablo

group 2
c-mccann
3b-zimmerman
sp-gallardo
of-jason bay
of-tori hunter
dh-vlad
of-colby rasmus
rp-ryan franklin
sp-dickey
sp-jaime garcia

I like Group 2 better basically because it has the best players.

[Darth Danielus]

Group 2 > Group 1.


help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=422412

[HOOTIE]

group 1
of-ichiro
of-ethier
sp-tommy hanson
sp-dan haren
sp-wandy
rp-soria
of-adam lind
1b/3b-pablo

group 2
c-mccann
3b-zimmerman
sp-gallardo
of-jason bay
of-tori hunter
dh-vlad
of-colby rasmus
rp-ryan franklin
sp-dickey
sp-jaime garcia

I like Group 2 better basically because it has the best players.

[Seanyfever]

of-ichiro
of-ethier
sp-tommy hanson
sp-dan haren
sp-wandy
rp-soria
of-adam lind
1b/3b-pablo

c-mccann
3b-zimmerman
sp-gallardo
of-jason bay *** I'd betempted to roll with my chances of some return value than any other pitchers, but so much injury and bad play last year.
of-tori hunter
dh-vlad << Still my fav player, but I can't tell you to take him.
of-colby rasmus
rp-ryan franklin
sp-dickey
sp-jaime garcia

Hope this was helpful. I'd be attmepting to swing a deal for a final player in this group B.
Return the favour!!!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=422387&p=3349505#p3349505