Trade Question std 5x5 roto keeper league

[Mateo de Lorenzo]

Ubaldo Jimenez for Carlos Gonzalez and Jamie Garcia.

Ubaldo will cost a 15th round draft pick in 2011's draft and then be a free agent in 2012

Carlos Gonzalez will cost a 17th round draft pick in 2011's draft and then be a free agent in 2012.

Jamie Garcia is not under contract and will cost a 20th round draft pick this year. For each subsequent year, he will cost a draft pick three rounds earlier then the previous year.

Seems like a bit much for CarGon as I plan to keep Garcia. I though about asking for Daniel Hudson in return (also costs a 20th rounder) or countering with Jhoulys Chacin instead of Garcia.

Any thoughts?

Is Jimenez for Cargon straight up pretty fair? I have two of the first five draft picks so I can easily replace a pitcher if needed (Lincecum, Lee, Sabathia and Kershaw are all available).

I am NOT planning on keeping Chacin so its kinda a freebie on that end and the other team has shown interest in him.

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd much rather have the CarGo side, especially keeping in mind that he'll only cost a 17th rounder.

[raiders_umpire]

I would want the CarGO side easily.

[MaudDib]

I'd much rather have the CarGo side, especially keeping in mind that he'll only cost a 17th rounder.

Pretty easily IMO.

[Darth Danielus]

Yeah -- I'd rather have cargo straight up, nevermind the cost of a lesser pick and such.


help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=422412