Matthias wrote:I'm not sure why you would dismiss QS on the grounds that it devalues one group and then promote a stat that devalues another.
I didn't dismiss QS - I just stated that it further devalues SP which it does. I'd dismiss holds, but if the guy wants to add QS and wants closers to dictate only 1/12 of the cats and have a minor influence on 2/12 then that's fine.
I have no idea on whether this is a H2H or Roto or how many teams it is, is Yahoo standard 12 teams? As long as the guy doesn't have some sort of setup where a team can only play relievers and punt W and K, then it will work just fine. Sure relievers will probably have a better K/BB than SP but they pitch maybe 30% of the innings, so you're still more likely to win K/BB because of your SP rather than your RP. I'd use it but then I'd always have an IP or GS minimum as well as maximum too.
Either works, it's just a matter of preference.