Dynasty Offer: Dunn/Nolasco/Papelbon for Rios/Wainwright/11t

[bujfan2030]

20 team Dynasty H2H 13cat(OBP, QS, Holds, K/9 instead of SO). We're in the middle of a slow draft. Non-salary, No FAAB. Roster 25 + 5 Minor league slots.
Would you do this
Rios/Wainwright/11th round pick for Dunn/Nolasco/Papelbon

My roster
C-
1B-Aubrey Huff
2B-Brandon Phillips
3B-Ryan Zimmerman
SS-Tsuyoshi Nikiosha
OF-Alex Rios
OF-Brett Gardner
OF-
UTil-
SP-Wainwright
SP-Hellickson
SP-
RP-Carlos Marmol
RP-
RP-
P-
P-
P-
Prospect-Mike Trout
Prospect-Brandon Belt
The boost in Power from Dunn would be great but Nolasco so risky could screw my pitching. Was thinking about a pitcher with my next pick. Already traded my 13th round pick, which would leave me with one pick in the next 60.
Pitchers still on the board: Lilly, Kuroda, Dempster, Chacin, Ian Kennedy, Edwin Jackson, De La Rosa, Colby Lewis, Josh Beckett, Vazquez, J. Zimmerman, Mcdonald, Shields, E. Santana, Anibal Sanchez, Wade Davis, Brett Cecil, Arroyo, Lackey, Pavano, Niese, Pelfrey, Peavy, J. Santana, Mike Minor, Bailey, Harang, Paulino, Bud Norris, Gavin Floyd, Jurrjens, Slowey, Burnett, Lowe, Travis Wood, Mike Leake, Niemann, Wells.

Pitching prospects Available
Julio Teheran
Michael Pineda
Jameson Tailllon
Matt Moore
Zach Britton
Shelby Miller
and pretty much everyone else except Kyle Drabek.

[Blaise28]

I would not want to go with Nolasco-Hellickson-#3 SP when Wainwright could have anchored my staff. You likley will have to take some risk with #3 anyway - probably a Peavy, Beckett, or Vazquez. I like having Hellickson but he may (should) end up on an innings limit.

[onitapgr]

I don't like this trade at all. You are giving up too much....Between Huff and Belt, you don't need Dunn (who could be DH only after this year, taking up that single UTIL spot)....And Nolasco could be great but thats what they always say. With Marmol, you can afford to wait til the late rounds to take a closer...

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=421853

[avsfan4ever33]

I wouldn't make the deal. Dunn would be very valuable in a league that uses OBP, but Wainwright is a stud and the dropoff from him to Nolasco is steep. I'm also not sold on Papelbon, who could very well be dealt or demoted if he struggles with the many options the Red Sox have in the bullpen.

[bujfan2030]

Thanx guys. you probably saved me from making a huge mistake.

[Elsy]

At first I was thinking yeah, but after looking at your roster and rest of your rotation I would hold off. See if you can just move Rios as his stock is prolly at an all time high.