Unfortunate that Aqua wasn't mafia scum, but if we were going to lynch a townie then I'm not sorry it was an apathetic, unhelpful one. The mafia killing steelerfan makes sense because he didn't give off much of a suspicious vibe (at least to me) over the course of Day 1.
Reviewing Day 1, there are three names that are sticking out to me. One is jfg. He lurked and lurked and bickered with people, and then swooped in with a 3rd vote on WaCoug. He did not vote for townie Aqua, but the Aqua lynch happened basically overnight so he might not have even had an opportunity to do so if he wanted to.
Among the people that voted for Aqua (Me, steelerfan513, WaCougMBS, bigken117, BigLebowski, wake), I'm very suspicious of both wake and BigLebowski. Myself, steelerfan, Coug, ken and even Lambskin and Mookie had discussed the idea of switching all our votes to Aqua near the end of Day 1, as we all thought he was suspicious and wanted to move the day along. But wake never joined that discussion. He gained a bunch of suspicion from lastings, tried to defend himself and then slapped a retaliation vote on lastings and then kind of kept quiet while people decided what bandwagon they wanted to jump on (his, lastings or Cougs.) Then when we all switch to Aqua, wake swoops in with the kill vote, almost immediately after Aqua insinuated he was a special-role townie.
Lebowski made all of 3 posts over that ridiculously long Day 1. He checked in and said "No lurking allowed." And then proceeded to lurk the rest of the day. He swooped in with a vote on lastings to "keep things interesting." Then disappeared again, until coming in and planting the 5th vote out of nowhere on Aqua. A few people (myself included) noted Lebowski's strange play, but nobody has made any sort of case against him. He's largely flown under the radar.
Lambskin tried to pump the brakes on Aqua after Aqua implied he had special abilities. I can't see a mafia member doing that when the Aqua train was at full-speed. Lambskin wasn't coming off as dirty to me before that, despite lastings crackpot theory, and that makes him seem even more pro-town.
Right now I'd like to hear some opinions on Lebowski and wake, the two who swooped in with the final two votes to kill Aqua. And I'd like to see if jfg pipes up now that Day 1 is over.