Need 2 more keepers

[Pepper Jack]

12 team 5x5 Roto
Normal positions plus IF, extra OF(4 total) and 2 Util
Pitching 2 SP, 2 RP, 4P
8 keepers

6 are pretty clear cut
C VMart
1B Youkilis
3B Zimmerman
SS Tulo
OF Choo
SP Felix

The last two i've narrowed down to these (but full roster below in case i am missing something)
2B Hill (bounce back?)
SS Jeter (milk one more year?)
OF Bourn/Gardner
SP Oswalt

Any help appreciated!

Full roster:
C Víctor Martínez
1B Kevin Youkilis
2B Aaron Hill
SS Derek Jeter
IF Troy Tulowitzki
3B Ryan Zimmerman
OF Michael Bourn
OF Shin-Soo Choo
OF Scott Podsednik
OF Andrés Torres
UT Brett Gardner
UT Luke Scott
BN Ramón Hernández
BN Ryan Raburn
BN Manny Ramírez

SP Félix Hernández
SP Roy Oswalt
RP Drew Storen
RP Huston Street
P Brandon Morrow
P Brian Fuentes
P Hong-Chih Kuo
P Travis Wood
BN Jason Hammel
BN Rich Harden
BN Vicente Padilla
BN Evan Meek

[steaksammich]

I'd definitely go with Jeter. His average should bounce back at least a little and 100 runs from your shortstop is still pretty good. I'm not a huge fan of your other options but I guess I'd go with Oswalt. You could do worse for a second starter.

[mkultra]

Since you've got Tulo, I wouldn't keep Jeter unless you've got a specific trade you can use him in. Otherwise, he doesn't have a lot of value to you as either an IF or U (not enough in either power or speed).

I'd keep Oswalt and Gardner.

[MaudDib]

Since you've got Tulo, I wouldn't keep Jeter unless you've got a specific trade you can use him in. Otherwise, he doesn't have a lot of value to you as either an IF or U (not enough in either power or speed).

I'd keep Oswalt and Gardner.

I will agree with this. Jeter is a nice SS but not a great Util play.

[SLBarnes]

Yea definitley go with Oswalt and Gardner.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=420722

I'm sorry about the full link, i don't know how to use the shortened part.