WHIR: Question about values in a Auction keeper League

[William Shea]

Facts you should know:

Classic 5x5 Roto 10 Team League
We can keep up to 7 players(but we don't have to)

We can keep seven players with there Value increasing 3$ after the first season 4$ after the second season and so on...

Here are a few guys i definitly want to keep:

C Geovany Soto 1$ in 2010=4$ in 2011
1B Joey Votto 27$(2011)
3B Michael Young 6$
OF Delmon Young 6$
OF Corey Hart 6$

Now the guys i'm uncertain about:

1B Ike Davis 9$
2B Ian Kinsler 22$
OF Shin-Soo Choo 13$
OF Hunter Pence 15$

I could keep two of them, i don't think that Kinsler is worth 22$ because of the injury risk, but
Choo and Pence for a combined 28 bucks should be a save bet, right?

[skmo2345]

Of that group, I would probably just keep Choo and throw back the rest.

[Remotethumb]

Yes, definitely Choo and I would also keep Pence at that price. I think Choo is a bargain. Ike Davis is priced a little cheap, but the problem with him (besides uncertainty) is you probably don't want to start him over some other choices you may have for the 1B position. But I think you could even consider Ike if you think he's gonna improve on his numbers from last year (or even stay on the same pace I guess)

I'm in a cap (keeper) league so I know how frustrating it is try to get answers to value questions. I'm struggling with having Drew Storen at $4 (but who keeps Washington RPs?) and Jaime Garcia at $8...I have much better options but those are some good prices...

[massespub]

Definitely keep Choo at $13. I think Pence should easily be worth $15 and maybe even $5-10 more than that.

[William Shea]

Thanks for your replies, here are the guys i will keep:

C Geovany Soto 4$
1B Joey Votto 27$
3B Michael Young 6$
OF Delmon Young 6$
OF Corey Hart 6$
OF Shin-Soo Choo 13$
OF Hunter Pence 15$
----------------------------
77 Dollar for 7 players, my OF is all set just like expensive positions like 1B and 3B