The Artful Dodger wrote:I would keep your first five plus McCutchen and Justin Upton. I like Ubaldo, but I think his second half was indicative of him regressing a bit. He's a top pitching talent, but I'd say you should keep your two most promising bats remaining.
This was my initial reaction as well, but I think leaving off Posey could be a mistake. I would probably keep Posey so that I wouldn't have to worry about drafting a C (unless its a 2 C league). Then I would either keep Hamels, or trade Jiminez for McCutchen/Upton.
If you can find a team who does not have any good SPs to keep, I'd make an offer of Hamels and Jiminez for a good power hitter as your 7th keeper.