12 team keeper league...who to keep? WHIR

[nyy28]

I can keep 2 players, but lose my pick in the round which they were taken last season.

My best options are:

Chris Young (ARI) - 25th round
Carlos Santana (CLE)- 24th round
Jered Weaver (LAA) - 10th round

I need to keep two of these guys and then toss the other one back into this year's draft. Standard 5x5 scoring.

I am 99% sure I'm keeping Santana, but not sure who else to keep. Weaver is obviously much more valuable, but is it worth the 15 round difference? I have a bad feeling that if I keep Chris Young he will kill my team BA all year, and steals can be made up for elsewhere. An ace SP in the 10th round is pretty valuable.

If you give me some decent advice post a link and I WHIR


Thanks

[RunReyesRun]

I tend to think CY was a little lucky last year, I don't want his BA on my team.

Keep Carlos and Weaver

[Demolition13]

I would go C Young and Santana. Weaver is a very good pitcher, but to get a 20/20 guy in the 25th round is tough to pass up.

[jmlevy]

I would go C Young and Santana. Weaver is a very good pitcher, but to get a 20/20 guy in the 25th round is tough to pass up.

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd go with Santana and CBY too.

[MaudDib]

I tend to think CY was a little lucky last year, I don't want his BA on my team.

Keep Carlos and Weaver

I think I would go this route. I don't trust Young.

[HOOTIE]

I'd go with Santana and CBY too.

[bigcrowleystyle]

Santana and CBY. Can't beat those values

[wkpdpack]

I think starting pitching is pretty deep this year. I'd go with Young and Santana. Just make sure you draft guys that bat for high average to account for these two low BA.

Please help with my post viewtopic.php?t=421452

[Padres Fan]

I say Young and Santana as well, at those values you are unlikely to get better

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=421468