Being a NL-Only league, that's a fair price. In our 12-team mixed auction/keeper league, he's kept at I believe 4.30 or so ($43 in rich league terms
). That said, do you have the options of trading in the offseason? Could you move Pujols for two or three players to shore up areas that you need help in? I'm not an expert in league-only teams, but I think you could improve your team overall and perhaps even save a little extra money to bid on players during your auction.
OF- Myers Jennings Heyward
U- Morneau, Ellsbury, Belt
SP-Price Greinke Fernandez Lee Miller
RP-Nathan, Grilli, Farquhar, Melacon