Mafia 2011 - Session IV signup thread

[Mookie4ever]

I don't like any of the new roles.

It just confuses things and interferes with getting reads on people. How can I tell if Wacky is the village idiot or not? Seriously?

I think that the addition of alll of these new roles takes most if not all of the skill out of the game and makes it a crapshoot.

[bigh0rt]

I don't like any of the new roles.

It just confuses things and interferes with getting reads on people. How can I tell if Wacky is the village idiot or not? Seriously?

I think that the addition of alll of these new roles takes most if not all of the skill out of the game and makes it a crapshoot.

This.

[Inukchuk]

Whatever is settled upon, I think the ISK should be mandated to kill every single night. He's the Insane Serial Killer, for chrissake.

agreed.

Also agreed...

I love being ISK... it is a life goal to win as one... fwiw, if yoda wasn't a moron 2 years back, i'd have had it in mafia xi...

[StlSluggers]

I don't want to play a game this huge.

[thedude]

I don't like any of the new roles.

It just confuses things and interferes with getting reads on people. How can I tell if Wacky is the village idiot or not? Seriously?

I think that the addition of alll of these new roles takes most if not all of the skill out of the game and makes it a crapshoot.

Having this many people confuses things. Adding one more informative role, while adding 6+ people should just to balance things out.

I am not a huge fan of the village idiot though.

[bigken117]

I don't want to play a game this huge.

that's what she said

[WaCougMBS]

So does everyone want to just have 5 mafioso with a boss, bodyguard, prostitute and 2 regulars and then an investigator, doctor, vigilante, watcher ISK and however many townies round things out depending on our final numbers? Want to just cap it at 21 and go 16 on 5 with those roles and maybe one added townie role?

Or are people amenable to the crime families but just don't want to cute up any individual townie roles, etc.?

[GiantsFan14]

So does everyone want to just have 5 mafioso with a boss, bodyguard, prostitute and 2 regulars and then an investigator, doctor, vigilante, watcher ISK and however many townies round things out depending on our final numbers? Want to just cap it at 21 and go 16 on 5 with those roles and maybe one added townie role?

Or are people amenable to the crime families but just don't want to cute up any individual townie roles, etc.?

5 v 16 sounds good to me

[TitanFan07]

Is the viligante even helpful to the town? I think I'd rather have a backup doctor or backup investigator than a crazy viligante...

[bigken117]

Option B but whatevs. Lets get rolling.