suggestions for my top 200 rankings? - Fantasy Baseball Cafe 2014 Fantasy Baseball Cafe
100% Deposit Bonus for Cafe Members!

Return to Baseball Leftovers

suggestions for my top 200 rankings?

Moderator: Baseball Moderators

suggestions for my top 200 rankings?

Postby Guest » Fri Mar 26, 2004 3:23 pm

New to fantasy baseball, and playing in a head to head league. Our catagories are runs, hits, HR, RBI, SB, walks, K, total bases, errors, average, ops- what is that? The pitching catagories are IP W L CG SHO SV H BB K ERA WHIP.

Obviously, most of ones rankings are personal tastes but are there any glaring oversights, ie injuries, ect..

1. Á. Rodríguez
2. A. Pujols
3. A. Soriano
4. V. Guerrero
5. C. Beltrán
6. T. Helton
7. B. Bonds
8. G. Sheffield
9. C. Delgado
10. R. Halladay
11. P. Martínez
12. M. Prior
13. M. Ramírez
14. N. Garciaparra
15. V. Wells
16. M. Ordóñez
17. C. Schilling
18. B. Boone
19. S. Sosa
20. J. Thome
21. P. Wilson
22. K. Wood
23. B. Abreu
24. M. Mussina
25. E. Gagne
26. M. Tejada
27. S. Rolen
28. J. Bagwell
29. T. Hudson
30. B. Wagner
31. R. Sexson
32. J. Giambi
33. A. Jones
34. K. Foulke
35. L. Berkman
36. M. Rivera
37. É. Rentería
38. R. Johnson
39. I. Suzuki
40. E. Chávez
41. J. Pierre
42. B. Zito
43. M. Piazza
44. J. Smoltz
45. E. Loaiza
46. G. Anderson
47. J. Vázquez
48. C. Jones
49. C. Lee
50. D. Lee
51. A. Huff
52. R. Palmeiro
53. J. Schmidt
54. D. Jeter
55. J. Beckett
56. B. Webb
57. J. López
58. T. Hoffman
59. A. Pettitte
60. E. Guardado
61. B. Colón
62. R. Ortiz
63. J. Edmonds
64. F. Thomas
65. R. Furcal
66. H. Nomo
67. M. Mulder
68. L. Hernández
69. B. Kim
70. R. Wolf
71. K. Millwood
72. J. Moyer
73. J. Santana
74. B. Giles
75. K. Brown
76. R. Sanders
77. M. Clement
78. J. Kent
79. J. Damon
80. R. Clemens
81. P. Nevin
82. J. Payton
83. L. González
84. R. Winn
85. J. Piñeiro
86. G. Maddux
87. O. Cabrera
88. M. Lowell
89. U. Urbina
90. T. Glaus
91. T. Nixon
92. T. Hunter
93. J. Encarnación
94. W. Williams
95. R. Oswalt
96. J. Posada
97. R. Hidalgo
98. W. Miller
99. R. Ibañez
100. S. Green
101. R. Mondesí
102. V. Padilla
103. K. Griffey Jr.
104. S. Finley
105. S. Ponson
106. C. Everett
107. S. Podsednik
108. M. Morris
109. I. Rodríguez
110. M. Redman
111. T. Wakefield
112. D. Lowe
113. J. Borowski
114. O. Dotel
115. D. Ortiz
116. K. Lofton
117. C. Zambrano
118. D. Wells
119. A. Ramírez
120. L. Walker
121. C. Sabathia
122. O. Pérez
123. D. Marte
124. M. Young
125. T. Percival
126. M. Mantei
127. L. Castillo
128. K. Millar
129. M. Giles
130. J. Gibbons
131. A. Benítez
132. M. Cameron
133. D. Willis
134. J. Varitek
135. J. Vidro
136. M. Alou
137. G. Jenkins
138. B. Mueller
139. É. Martínez
140. J. González
141. B. Wilkerson
142. B. Radke
143. F. Cordero
144. M. Sweeney
145. D. Young
146. J. Isringhausen
147. C. Crawford
148. Á. Berroa
149. R. Baldelli
150. S. Hillenbrand
151. H. Blalock
152. B. Looper
153. J. Guillén
154. J. Washburn
155. M. Ensberg
156. F. García
157. J. Jones
158. M. Buehrle
159. B. Penny
160. R. Ortiz
161. B. Anderson
162. J. Nathan
163. C. Koskie
164. B. Myers
165. B. Williams
166. C. Floyd
167. J. Rollins
168. H. Matsui
169. M. Hampton
170. M. Mora
171. D. Erstad
172. J. Kendall
173. E. Durazo
174. J. Burnitz
175. M. Lieberthal
176. E. Hinske
177. T. Salmon
178. M. Loretta
179. A. Dunn
180. M. Bradley
181. C. Patterson
182. T. Glavine
183. A. Pierzynski
184. R. Klesko
185. M. Teixeira
186. D. Kolb
187. S. Chacón
188. D. Mientkiewicz
189. A. Béltre
190. C. Guzmán
191. J. Contreras
192. L. Matos
193. J. Phelps
194. M. Herges
195. A. Rhodes
196. P. Burrell
197. M. Byrd
198. K. Rueter
199. Á. Cintrón
200. M. MacDougal
201. R. Aurilia
202. P. Konerko
203. A. López
204. D. Roberts
205. J. Drew
206. J. Mesa
207. A. Kearns
208. D. Graves
209. P. Lo Duca
210. M. LeCroy
211. S. Burroughs
212. J. Weaver
213. J. Reyes
214. R. Harden
Guest


Home Cafe: Football
Friendliness: %

Postby inkubus » Fri Mar 26, 2004 3:24 pm

Halladay at 10 and Manny at 13.. that MUST be a personal taste.
inkubus
Minor League Mentor
Minor League Mentor

User avatar
Graphics Expert
Posts: 644
Joined: 14 Mar 2004
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Tampa

Postby Guest » Fri Mar 26, 2004 3:26 pm

Where do you think they should fall? I never claimed I was a seasoned pro- this is my first draft guys- be kind!
Guest


Home Cafe: Football
Friendliness: %

Postby orangecrushv » Fri Mar 26, 2004 3:55 pm

Too high:
Beckett @ 55, Webb @ 56 (I'd rank Colon above both of them -- I got Beckett in 14th round and Webb in the 11th)

Garcia @ 156 (I picked him off waivers in one 10 team league and was picked in 20 round of 9 team league)

*****

Too low:
Blalock @ 151 (8th round in 9 team league, 6th round in 10 team league)

Giles @74 (Taken in 4th round in 10 team league and 6th in 9 team league)

Hope this helps some!
-Rich
orangecrushv
Minor League Mentor
Minor League Mentor

User avatar

Posts: 414
Joined: 19 Mar 2003
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Dallas, TX

Postby Cornbread Maxwell » Fri Mar 26, 2004 4:14 pm

Pettitte is way way too high
Oswalt is way too low
K Brown is too low
Having R. Sanders @76 must be a joke.

All of these should be bumped up quite a bit:

Posada, M. Morris, Pudge, Percival, M. Giles, J. Gonzalez, Sweeney, Isri, Blalock, Patterson, Teixeira, Contreras, Rhodes Drew, and Kearns
Image
Cornbread Maxwell
Hall of Fame Hero
Hall of Fame Hero

User avatar
CafeholicFantasy ExpertPick 3 ChampionSweet 16 Survivor
Posts: 5694
Joined: 7 Jul 2003
Home Cafe: Football

Postby Ridgerunner » Fri Mar 26, 2004 4:21 pm

the other Giles should be moved up too. I would take him over L. Castillo. He's my fourth rated 2b.
RR
Ridgerunner
College Coach
College Coach

User avatar

Posts: 120
Joined: 21 Mar 2004
Home Cafe: Baseball

Postby Guest » Fri Mar 26, 2004 5:08 pm

OK I have tried to implement some of those suggestions? Any other ideas? Thanks!

New top 200.
1. Á. Rodríguez
2. A. Pujols
3. A. Soriano
4. V. Guerrero
5. C. Beltrán
6. T. Helton
7. B. Bonds
8. G. Sheffield
9. C. Delgado
10. R. Halladay
11. P. Martínez
12. M. Prior
13. M. Ramírez
14. N. Garciaparra
15. V. Wells
16. M. Ordóñez
17. C. Schilling
18. B. Boone
19. S. Sosa
20. J. Thome
21. P. Wilson
22. K. Wood
23. R. Oswalt
24. B. Abreu
25. M. Mussina
26. E. Gagne
27. M. Tejada
28. L. Berkman
29. S. Rolen
30. J. Bagwell
31. T. Hudson
32. B. Wagner
33. R. Sexson
34. J. Giambi
35. A. Jones
36. K. Brown
37. R. Johnson
38. K. Foulke
39. M. Rivera
40. É. Rentería
41. I. Suzuki
42. E. Chávez
43. B. Zito
44. M. Piazza
45. J. Smoltz
46. M. Morris
47. G. Anderson
48. B. Giles
49. J. Vázquez
50. C. Jones
51. M. Mulder
52. C. Lee
53. D. Lee
54. A. Huff
55. J. Posada
56. R. Palmeiro
57. J. Schmidt
58. D. Jeter
59. J. Beckett
60. S. Green
61. B. Webb
62. J. Kent
63. J. López
64. T. Hoffman
65. E. Guardado
66. O. Cabrera
67. J. Pierre
68. B. Colón
69. R. Ortiz
70. E. Loaiza
71. J. Edmonds
72. R. Clemens
73. F. Thomas
74. R. Furcal
75. H. Nomo
76. C. Zambrano
77. L. Hernández
78. B. Kim
79. M. Teixeira
80. R. Wolf
81. K. Millwood
82. J. Moyer
83. J. Santana
84. M. Lowell
85. J. Damon
86. P. Nevin
87. J. Payton
88. L. González
89. R. Winn
90. J. Piñeiro
91. G. Maddux
92. H. Blalock
93. O. Dotel
94. U. Urbina
95. T. Glaus
96. T. Hunter
97. A. Pettitte
98. J. Encarnación
99. W. Williams
100. R. Hidalgo
101. D. Lowe
102. J. Vidro
103. W. Miller
104. R. Ibañez
105. R. Mondesí
106. V. Padilla
107. K. Griffey Jr.
108. S. Finley
109. S. Ponson
110. C. Everett
111. M. Lieberthal
112. S. Podsednik
113. J. Isringhausen
114. T. Percival
115. I. Rodríguez
116. T. Wakefield
117. T. Nixon
118. J. Borowski
119. D. Ortiz
120. R. Sanders
121. A. Ramírez
122. L. Walker
123. C. Sabathia
124. O. Pérez
125. C. Patterson
126. M. Young
127. M. Mantei
128. L. Castillo
129. K. Millar
130. M. Giles
131. J. Gibbons
132. A. Benítez
133. M. Cameron
134. D. Willis
135. J. Contreras
136. M. Redman
137. J. Varitek
138. M. Alou
139. G. Jenkins
140. B. Mueller
141. J. Reyes
142. M. Ensberg
143. É. Martínez
144. J. González
145. M. Buehrle
146. B. Radke
147. F. Cordero
148. M. Sweeney
149. D. Young
150. C. Crawford
151. K. Lofton
152. A. Rhodes
153. Á. Berroa
154. R. Baldelli
155. S. Hillenbrand
156. B. Looper
157. J. Guillén
158. J. Washburn
159. F. García
160. A. López
161. B. Penny
162. P. Burrell
163. R. Ortiz
164. B. Anderson
165. J. Nathan
166. J. Drew
167. A. Kearns
168. C. Koskie
169. P. Lo Duca
170. B. Wilkerson
171. B. Myers
172. B. Williams
173. C. Floyd
174. J. Rollins
175. H. Matsui
176. M. Hampton
177. M. Clement
178. M. Mora
179. D. Erstad
180. J. Kendall
181. E. Durazo
182. J. Burnitz
183. E. Hinske
184. T. Salmon
185. M. LeCroy
186. M. Loretta
187. A. Dunn
188. M. Bradley
189. Á. Cintrón
190. T. Glavine
191. A. Pierzynski
192. J. Jones
193. R. Klesko
194. D. Kolb
195. S. Chacón
196. D. Mientkiewicz
197. A. Béltre
198. C. Guzmán
199. L. Matos
200. J. Phelps
201. M. Herges
202. M. Byrd
203. K. Rueter
204. M. MacDougal
205. R. Aurilia
206. P. Konerko
207. D. Roberts
208. J. Mesa
209. D. Graves
210. S. Burroughs
211. J. Weaver
212. R. Harden
213. D. Marte
214. D. Wells
Guest


Home Cafe: Football
Friendliness: %

Postby CBMGreatOne » Fri Mar 26, 2004 5:25 pm

It's really tough to rank with all of those categories; in a lot of ways it should turn your rankings upside down.

For instance SBs aren't nearly as important in a 10x10 as in a 5x5. Base Stealers lose a lot of value. Also, a lot of guys who have decent batting averages are not so good in BB, K, and OPS, ie. Soriano, I'd probably move Vlad up to the third spot because he's a stud in all of those categories.

Also, guys like Giambi and Brian Giles, who are patient hitters and draw a lot of walks, have very high BB, and OPS numbers, and in the case of Giles very low Ks.

I really wouldn't know where to begin rating those players, but those are just a handful of things to keep in mind.
CBMGreatOne
General Manager
General Manager

User avatar

Posts: 3166
(Past Year: 89)
Joined: 30 May 2003
Home Cafe: Baseball


Return to Baseball Leftovers

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests

Forums Articles & Tips Sleepers Rankings Leagues


Today's Games
Thursday, Aug. 28
(All times are EST, weather icons show forecast for game time)

Chi Cubs at Cincinnati
(12:35 pm)
NY Yankees at Detroit
(1:08 pm)
Colorado at San Francisco
(3:45 pm)
Tampa Bay at Baltimore
(7:05 pm)
Atlanta at NY Mets
(7:10 pm)
Cleveland at Chi White Sox
(8:10 pm)
Texas at Houston
(8:10 pm)
Minnesota at Kansas City
(8:10 pm)
Oakland at LA Angels
(10:05 pm)

  • Fantasy Baseball
  • Article Submissions
  • Privacy Statement
  • Site Survey 
  • Contact