Help me pick rest of keepers 12 team league H2H

[oakscorps]

We keep 10 and I'm in finals, stats are listed below, need 3 more to keep. Thinking Bautista, Gardner, and either Roberts or Beltre but wanted to get opinions, WHIR. Definately no more pitchers other then those two.

Trends Batting
R 1B HR RBI SB BB AVG
C Matt Wieters
1B Adrian Gonzalez ****
2B Dan Uggla ****
3B Adrian Beltre
SS Elvis Andrus ****
OF Ryan Braun ****
OF Chris Young ****
OF Vernon Wells
Util Jose Bautista
BN Brett Gardner
BN Brian Roberts

Trends Pitching
W SV K HLD ERA WHIP QS
SP Jered Weaver ****
SP John Danks
SP Brett Anderson
Justin Verlander ******
P Carlos Zambrano
P Fausto Carmona
P Ricky Romero
BN Derek Lowe
BN Daniel Hudson
BN Colby Lewis

[zippytrash]

You wouldn't want to keep any of those other pitchers anyway.

I would go Bautista, Gardner, and Beltre.

Third base is still thin, and having trade options( a great time to sell high on Bautista). Also, Roberts can't seem to keep himself on the field and Gardner will bring the SB's that Roberts woud otherwise provide.... however you never know how the offseason will shake out. Maybe the yanks bring in Crawford and trade Gardner for pitching since he's good and, more importantly, cheap. I assume you don't have to pick too soon, but if you did I would go with the above list.

Take a look at mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=419609

[Phillip]

I would agree generally with your last poster, for similar and different reasons. Besides Roberts having health issues, having Uggla and no MI or IF position makes Roberts very redundant. I am not as high on Gardner, but know that there are people who have reasons for being higher on him and the singles category is a goo reason for him. Even if Beltre regresses a little, the previous poster is right about the thinness of 3B and how Bautista and Beltre would present either trade chips or would generally weaken other players 3B position. I think that Bautista, Gardner and Beltre might all be candidates to regress, but they are your best options for players 8-10 and the chances of all 3 or even 2 of 3 regressing are lower, just don't be surprised if at least one does.


Please help here: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=419611