Choose 4 Keeps -- WHIR

[Jetsfan]

H2H 10-team keeper
Cats: R HR RBI SB AVG W SV K ERA WHIP
Pick any 4 keeps...basically leaning towards taking 4 bats but dunno if CC is too much to give up.
also keep in mind i have 2 late 1st rounders also...probably 7th and 10th picks


C Geovany Soto
1B Joey Votto
2B Howie Kendrick
3B Mark Reynolds
SS Rafael Furcal
OF Carlos González
OF Adam Lind
OF Drew Stubbs
Util Ryan Braun
Util Miguel Cabrera
BN Curtis Granderson
BN Josh Hamilton

SP John Danks
SP Daniel Hudson
RP José Valverde
RP Billy Wagner
P Mariano Rivera
P Brandon Lyon
P Hisanori Takahashi
P Clay Hensley
BN Colby Lewis
BN Jhoulys Chacin
BN CC Sabathia
DL Stephen Strasburg


pitching might look kinda weird right now....just a strat for champ week to lock up saves

Thanks in advance, WHIR

[P.S.]

I may try to trade CarGo... for instance someone with a weak back end of keepers might take him along with Sabathia for a better keeper. If you're unable to trade before locking in the keepers though, I'd agree with the four you have. Hamilton is not a bad choice either, but I'd also think you might be able to find a buyer for him with what he's done this year.

Thoughts on mine?

[Phillip]

I would tend to agree with the previous poster. If trades are possible I would explore them. Cabrera and Votto to me are the no-brainers. I would agree about hitter over pitcher. It would be a bit closer for me b/w the 3 OFs. CarGo has the best stats of the season, but a lot of sabermetrics are predicting a worse season next year. Braun has had the most consistency, but had the worse season of the 3 by far. Hamilton has been great when healthy, but health is a big question with him. If you can pursue trades I would look at that. If the health issue with Hamilton is not as big of an issue I would go with him and Braun, but if health is an issue I would go with Braun and CarGo. CarGo just seems like the most likely to fall off (even if not precipitously) next year.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=419278