Curtis or BJ?

[galacticat]

I must choose between Curtis Granderson and BJ Upton for the remainder of the regular season and playoff run, the other guy *must* be put on waivers. My team is well balanced offensively, and I value production in all 5 standard offensive categories pretty much equally. I'm leaning ever so slightly towards Granderson right now, but wavering. Opinion?

[bobopal]

Id say granderson this because he is in a better position in the yankees lineup to be a more productive player all around. The only thing upton has on granderson is steals and even though grandersons average isnt great hes been coming on of late and has better peripheral numbers.

help
viewtopic.php?t=418759

[Bjorne Greece]

I'd go Upton. Elite steals. Only a couple less HRs. More runs, more RBI. Both have terrible batting averages.

opinion please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=418763

[bazzy_51]

I say BJ. Hawpe's signing kind of scares me because I feel a resurgence coming, which would completely LOG JAM that OF, but BJ is the better value pick as it stands right now.

[Seanyfever]

BJ. I have him and while frustrated, I have been playing him more regularly recently.



Help me out?!
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=418783