Keeper league trade

[joe112]

Team 1 gets, Mark Reynolds, Jose Lopez and Billy Wagner.
*
Team 2 gets Ian Kinsler, Carlos Quentin and Daniel Hudson.
*
Who wins in this keeper league trade?

[diesek]

It really depends on what needs the trade fills.

But judging purely by amount of talent exchanged, Team 2 wins. The trade might not help the team this late in the season but the players acquired could help in the coming seasons.

[Wadderboiz]

Short term team #1 wins
Long term and overall team #2 wins