Dynasty Trade w/prospects...is it obvious? WHIR

[issaquah stud]

Team 1 Gets: Hughes, Matusz, Manny Machado (minor league team--protected and not on active roster)
Team 2 gets: Wandy Rodriguez, David Aardsma, Max Kepler (minor league team too).

this is a league that has an innings pitched limit of 1500, and is a 6x6 scoring year long roto. The extra categoreis are Holds and On Base %. Right now one Team 1 is in 2nd place and Team 2 is in 4th but almost 20 points out if first. I'll past the 2 rosters below.

Which team gets the better deal? I think it's obvious but the guy I'm trading with doesn't think so. I ALWAYS respond to others so be sure to leave a link of your own question.

If you have time please say why the team gets the better end of it.

Team 2:
PLAYER, TEAM POS
Miguel Montero, Ari C S
Joey Votto, Cin 1B S
Rickie Weeks, Mil 2B S
Alex Rodriguez, NYY 3B S
Alcides Escobar, Mil SS S
Gordon Beckham, CWS 3B, 2B S
Michael Young, Tex 3B
Jayson Werth, Phi OF S
Delmon Young, Min OF S
Carlos Quentin, CWS OF, DH S
Peter Bourjos, LAA OF
Jason Kubel, Min OF, DH S
Angel Pagan, NYM OF S
Vernon Wells, Tor OF

Jesus Montero, NYY C
Nyjer Morgan*, Was OF DL15
J.J. Hardy, Min SS DTD
Grady Sizemore*, Cle OF DL15

PLAYER, TEAM POS
Ryan Franklin, StL RP
Hong-Chih Kuo, LAD RP
Michael Wuertz, Oak RP
Ryan Madson, Phi RP
Phil Hughes, NYY SP, RP PP
Brian Matusz, Bal SP
Joba Chamberlain, NYY SP, RP
Mike Adams, SD RP
Aaron Heilman, Ari RP

Josh Johnson, Fla SP
Francisco Liriano, Min SP
Ervin Santana, LAA SP PP
Kevin Slowey, Min SP DTD
Joaquin Benoit, TB RP
Colby Lewis, Tex SP PP
Daisuke Matsuzaka, Bos SP
Joel Zumaya*, Det RP DL60

Team 1
PLAYER, TEAM POS
Brian McCann, Atl C S
Adrian Gonzalez, SD 1B
Brandon Phillips, Cin 2B S
Evan Longoria, TB 3B
Stephen Drew, Ari SS S
Brian Roberts, Bal 2B
Placido Polanco, Phi 2B, 3B S
Justin Upton, Ari OF S
Matt Kemp, LAD OF S
Carlos Gonzalez, Col OF S
Adam Lind, Tor OF, DH
Travis Snider, Tor OF
Ty Wigginton, Bal 3B, 1B, 2B, DH
Felix Pie, Bal OF

Scott Rolen, Cin 3B S
Jason Bartlett, TB SS
Matt Joyce, TB OF, DH
Jarrod Saltalamacchia, Bos C
Chris Coghlan*, Fla OF DL15


PLAYER, TEAM POS
David Aardsma, Sea RP
Jose Valverde, Det RP
Matt Thornton, CWS RP
Sean Marshall, ChC SP, RP
Felix Hernandez, Sea SP
Jonny Venters, Atl SP, RP
Koji Uehara, Bal SP, RP
Carlos Marmol, ChC RP
Rafael Soriano, TB RP

Brett Anderson, Oak SP
Clayton Kershaw, LAD SP
Wandy Rodriguez, Hou SP
Dallas Braden, Oak SP
Brian Duensing, Min SP, RP PP
Jake Arrieta, Bal SP

[lane_anasazi2]

This one looks obvious to me, too. Especially in a dynasty league, Hughes > Wandy, Matusz > Aardsma, and Machado > Kepler.

Team 2 isn't quite getting hosed, but it's close.

Here's mine: viewtopic.php?t=418267

[issaquah stud]

bump

[CubsFan4Life23]

team 1 gets th better deal...no brainer to me

help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=418337

[hecrey91]

Pretty much what everyone else has said. Team 1 is winning big here.

[Hit Factory]

Hey man thanks for the help with mine. I have to concur with the others, team 1 is getting the better end of this deal...Hughes+Matusz is a nice combo.

[maurerscouting]

Team 1 has the edge in that trade...

help me?

viewtopic.php?t=418406