Trade too Lopsided?

[javens]

Trade just got accepted today and its raising some eyebrows.

Buster Posey
Stephen Strasburg
Matt Kemp

for

Carl Crawford
Ryan Howard

The trade between a first place team (the team that would get Crawford and Howard) and a team that is in 6th place in a league that takes the top 4. The league is for $600.

[snichols84]

No. There's enough value going both ways. I've seen a lot worse.

[bigmck]

Do not judge a trade on "Would I make this trade?". Judge it on the merits of "Is this totally unfair?" == All trades do not have to be even. Someone always gets the advantage. This is not a veto trade.

[DaSh 1s]

If it's not a keeper, I'd veto. That is a Clown-Status trade. Especially when its publicly known Strasburg will be shut down to innings.

[dleoboyd]

If this is a keeper league I don't think anyone bats an eyelid. Even in a re-draft league this is not veto-worthy. Considering Howard's ankle and declining power it's quite conceivable that the younger trio outperforms the veteran duo over the balance of the season.