M. Tejada & D. Lowe FOR C. Johnson & C. Lewis

[Fantasy Addict]

Hey everyone. I was wondering if you all could help me with something. Today, a trade was accepted where TEAM A is giving M. Tejada SD (3B/SS) and D. Lowe ATL (SP) for TEAM B's C. Johnson HOU (3B) and C. Lewis TEX (SP). This is a 12 team head to head league where the competition is very good. There are many fighting for the 5th and 6th seed. TEAM A is in 5th place right now. TEAM B is realistically out of contention.

I posted http://www.fantasycafe.com on our league board. This is so the league can use this forum as a tool to allow newer managers a place to post trades that have been offered to them. You all are great in notifying someone whether or not a trade is good or bad using research and logic to support your opinion. Your responses to this post will be a great example for everyone in my league.

I am not asking any of you to post your opinions on whether or not this trade should be vetoed, but instead to offer your opinions on whether or not TEAM B should have accepted this trade and why. I am trying to use this particular post as an example for newer managers in my league to want to use fantasycafe.com's forum resources in the future when it comes to trades.

Here are the league settings:

Head to Head Top 6 teams make the playoffs. There are 4 more weeks left in the fantasy regular season.

HITTING

R...HR...RBI...SB...BB...K...TB(total bases)...F%(Fielding percentage)...AVG

PITCHING

W...L...SV...BB...K...ERA...WHIP...K/9

Team A

HITTERS

C --empty--
1B Paul Konerko
(CWS - 1B)
2B Aaron Hill
(Tor - 2B)
3B Miguel Tejada
(SD - 3B,SS)
SS Elvis Andrus
(Tex - SS)
LF Juan Pierre
(CWS - LF,CF)
CF Dexter Fowler
(Col - CF)
RF Jayson Werth
(Phi - CF,RF)
Util Brennan Boesch
(Det - LF,RF)
Util Michael Cuddyer
(Min - 1B,3B,RF)
BN Carl Crawford
(TB - LF)
BN Mark Teixeira
(NYY - 1B)
BN Curtis Granderson
(NYY - CF)
DL Martín Prado
(Atl - 1B,2B,3B) DL
DL Chris Coghlan
(Fla - LF) DL


PITCHERS

SP Justin Verlander
(Det - SP)
SP Trevor Cahill
(Oak - SP)
SP Jair Jurrjens
(Atl - SP)
SP Jason Vargas
(Sea - SP,RP)
RP Billy Wagner
(Atl - RP)
RP Joaquín Benoit
(TB - RP)
RP R.A. Dickey
(NYM - SP,RP)
P Tommy Hunter
(Tex - SP)
P Derek Lowe
(Atl - SP)
BN Gio González
(Oak - SP)
BN Ricky Nolasco
(Fla - SP)
BN Jeff Niemann
(TB - SP) DL
BN Doug Fister
(Sea - SP)
BN Javier Vázquez
(NYY - SP)


TEAM B

HITTERS

C Matt Wieters
(Bal - C)
1B Gaby Sánchez
(Fla - 1B)
2B Maicer Izturis
(LAA - 2B,3B,SS)
3B Álex Rodríguez
(NYY - 3B)
SS Erick Aybar
(LAA - SS)
LF Alex Gordon
(KC - 3B,LF)
CF Jon Jay
(StL - CF,RF)
RF Corey Hart
(Mil - RF)
Util Ryan Ludwick
(SD - RF)
Util Chris Johnson
(Hou - 3B)
BN Rafael Furcal
(LAD - SS)
BN Ben Zobrist
(TB - 1B,2B,SS,CF,RF)
BN Brett Wallace
(Hou - 1B,3B)
DL Manny Ramírez
(LAD - LF) DL
DL Shane Victorino
(Phi - CF) DL

PITCHERS

SP Adam Wainwright
(StL - SP)
SP Ricky Romero
(Tor - SP)
SP Josh Beckett
(Bos - SP)
SP Jaime García
(StL - SP,RP)
RP Ryan Madson
(Phi - RP)
RP Joba Chamberlain
(NYY - SP,RP)
RP David Robertson
(NYY - RP)
P Jon Garland
(SD - SP)
P Jorge De La Rosa
(Col - SP)
BN Edinson Vólquez
(Cin - SP)
BN Anibal Sánchez
(Fla - SP)
BN Colby Lewis
(Tex - SP,RP)
BN C.J. Wilson
(Tex - SP,RP)

[Fantasy Addict]

BUMP...

The trade was vetoed by the league today. I, as commish abstained from the voting. Can someone enlighten us on why this trade is, or is not fair? I would like to post this particular post on my league home page so the managers in our league will have an example of how http://www.fantasycafe.com can help in the future when it comes to trades.

Thanks!

WHIR (I forgot to mention that in my first post)