Luke Scott for David Murphy and Scott Baker, WHIR

[mschulm2]

I was offered Scott Baker and David Murphy for Luke Scott. I need another pitcher, but am not sure that Baker is worth the price of Scott and Murphy would be nothing more than a backup to me. Any help would be much appreciated and would be glad to return the favor.


20 Team Keeper League with 8 keepers, regardless of draft position.

Stats are runs, hrs, rbis, sbs, avg, obp for hitters and w, svs, hlds, ks ,era, whip for pitchers

C - Mike Napoli, Yadier Molina
1B - Lance Berkman, Russell Branyan
2B - Kelly Johnon, Blake Dewitt
3B - Scott Rolen
SS - Asdrubal Cabrera
LF - Luke Scott, Fred Lewis
CF - Shane Victorino, Mitch Maier
RF - Justin Upton, Travis Snider, Nick Swisher
OF, Util spot

SP - Jon Lester, Felix Hernandez, Mat Latos, Colby Lewis, Brett Cecil, Vincente Padilla
RP - Matt Lindstrom, Jason Frasor, Kevin Jepsen, Craig Breslow, Joe Thatcher

[rockchalk]

I wouldn't do it. Baker isn't really an upgrade just depth for you and the hit at LF would be greater than any help Baker would be this year.

Help with mine? Thanks.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=418011&p=3309557#p3309557

[mschulm2]

Thanks for your input. Thats what I am thinking too. Im seeing if I can get someone half decent for Lewis or even Snider, but no one is biting yet.