Hudson/Utley for Phillips/Hughes WHIR

[Chief Wahoo]

In a 12-team H2H with 6x6 scoring (standard 5x5 plus OPS and quality starts). I'm looking for one more reliable arm to steady my rotation as I go into the playoffs next month. I was offered Tim Hudson and Chase Utley for Brandon Phillips and Phil Hughes. I could care less about Hughes, but I would have with waiver wire pickups for the rest of the way until Utley comes back. The best out there at the moment are Keppinger, Infante, Desmond, and the like. This is all still assuming Utley comes back in form.

So what do I do? It sounds great in theory, but some things have to break my way for it to go right. WHIR, as always. Thanks!