Actually posting this for a friend, but I'll give you my input on your question asap.
16-teamer, H2H, standard 5x5. My 1B's are Ike Davis and Cantu (one plays Util), and my pitchers are WanRam, Dickey, Duke, Slowey, Morrow, and Leake.
Someone has offered me Billy Butler for Wandy straight-up. Do I jump on this? Thanks a bunch.