"Who wins?" scenarios: DLee/JSanchez for Cantu/OF (WHIR)

[KJROD20]

12 team h2h points 10-keeper league. Without rosters, who wins these deals?

Derek Lee & Jonathan Sanchez for:

1. Jorge Cantu & Delmon Young
2. Jorge Cantu & Angel Pagan
3. Jorge Cantu & Andres Torres
4. Jorge Cantu & Josh Willingham

what would you consider the most even of the bunch? FWIW, I don't think any of the players involved are potential keepers, the exception being Delmon Young.

[LARS929]

12 team h2h points 10-keeper league. Without rosters, who wins these deals?

Derek Lee & Jonathan Sanchez for:

1. Jorge Cantu & Delmon Young
2. Jorge Cantu & Angel Pagan
3. Jorge Cantu & Andres Torres
4. Jorge Cantu & Josh Willingham

what would you consider the most even of the bunch? FWIW, I don't think any of the players involved are potential keepers, the exception being Delmon Young.

I think that the MOST even is Cantu and Young, but I don't really think any are all that fair

[Holein1]

Can I take non of the above. I would not give up lee and sanchez for any of those.

please help

JB@#5903

[KJROD20]

Wow. I'm kind of surprised it seems like no-brainers for all of them. In our points league, DY is the 17th highest scoring offensive player, Angel Pagan 24th. Even Torres and Willingham are in the top 60 overall.

Basically someone is offering me Lee and Sanchez for Cantu and and OF, and they are: Choo, Rios, DY, Pagan, Torres, and the Hammer. I'm keeping Choo and Rios for next year so I don't want to give them up, and DY i'm debating keeping.

Are Lee and Sanchez really worth that much more than Cantu and one of the OFers?

[bobopal]

I would say Lee and Sanchez isn't worth it. Lee is having a horrid season and is completely worthless in my book also Sanchez although he has good numbers his WHIP is high like it usually is and having a high WHIP can lead to a high ERA so he is a risk. Maybe for one of the lesser OF but definitely not Young or Pagan.