I would be getting Halladay and giving Hanson, Scherzer and Axford.
Should I do the deal? The other guy needs saves badly and also needs SP depth.
10 team league, h2h with normal 5x5 stats plus OBP, doubles, QS, k/9. Also is a keeper league where we keep 8 players.
My team: C. V-mart 1b: Pujols 2b: Cano SS: Tulowitski 3b: Reynolds MI: Alexei Ramirez CI: Teixera OF: Carlos Lee OF: C. Young OF: Pence OF: Bautista Util: Carl Crawford
I would do this trade in a second. We're talking about the best pitcher in fantasy baseball. He's definitely worth two 3rd-tier pitchers and a closer. You have plenty of SP depth to do this move and 3 closers should be enough in a h2h league. Not to mention he's a great keeper.