Should I trade Votto or Ellsbury for this?(WHIR)

[Ars3nal]

Thanks, maybe I will try to shop ARod around and see what I can get. What if I could get a better OF than Boesch in the Ellsbury deal like Choo? Think that would be fair and doable? Any other opinions out there about these two offers? All replies answered. Thanks.

Even with Choo in that deal, I don't love it. I just hate that value for Ellsbury and Marmol. I'm not a big VMart guy at all, and for good reason - he just doesn't produce any more. Adding him in the deal only marginally improves your catcher spot. It would be nice for you to have an upgrade over Kendall, but I think this is the best way to do it. I think your team is better just staying put, as far as the first deal is concerned.

[sigriffey]

See if you can shop A-Rod and Beltran for, say, Ryan Zimmerman and an ace like a CC or even a Haren. One more legit ace would bolster your staff I think, and I am not sure Cahill is that guy.

[dubstar]

I think the value is best on the Votto deal, however I don't think I would move him in this format