Posey or Mauer?

[usmc0842]

I am Being offered

Joe Mauer
Aramis Ramirez
John Axford

for

Buster Posey
Luke scott
Houston Street

The only thing that is keeping me from doing it is Posey, is he worth giving up, would appreciate any thoughts on the deal.

[onitapgr]

That's a tough one....if you were going to give up Posey, Mauer would be the only C right now that I would do it for. If you need 3B, A-Ram is a good pick-up. Axford is doing great but Hoffman might take some save chances this year.

If it's a keeper then I would probably do it because A-Ram is a solid keeper, if not I would stay put.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=417357

[freeling_prideful]

This is a great deal. Posey is going to be a solid catcher but it's not like Mauer is old and about to fall off a cliff. Even w/ a normal catcher decline timeline, he'll have 2-3 more peak seasons in him, during which you could probably trade him for a much better prospect than Posey.

Help with mine?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=417359