McCutchen or Ad.Jones?

[guyincognito]

Take a look at my roster and let me know if you think either of these deals makes sense for me:

1) give Dempster, get McCutchen
2) give Scherzer, get Adam Jones

or do I just stay put?

14 team, H2H, Keeper League (keep 2)
B Cats: Avg, E, H, HR, PP, R, RBI, SB
P Cats: W, L, K, QS, ERA, WHIP, HD, S

C - B.Posey
1B - M.Teixeira
2B - R.Weeks
SS - Al.Ramirez
3B - E.Longoria
OF - J.Heyward, B.Boesch, A.Pagan
DH - R.Ibanez
U - C.Barmes
Bench - M.Wieters, L.Scott, J.Thome
DL - J.Ellsbury
SP - A.Wainwright, J.Santana, R.Oswalt, R.Dempster
RP - F.Rodriguez, B.Wagner, C.Marmol, R.Perry, J.Venters
Bench - M.Latos, M.Scherzer, B.Morrow
DL - B.Penny
Minors - B.Wallace

[fast dogs]

I'd take McCutchen w/o thinking twice

[Bea Arthur]

I'd take McCutchen w/o thinking twice

This.

Help w/mine? viewtopic.php?t=417273

[bobnerns]

I would do either one of these, but I really like the McCutchen trade, especially if its a keeper league.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=417311

[saemick]

McCutchen without a doubt. he'll come back and will be a very good piece for you, while Dempster will just be decent...and you definitely have the SP depth

as for the 2nd one, I just don't trust Jones and Scherzer has been great since getting called back up.

thanks for the help with mine. I added a 2nd question if you could give me a hand:

viewtopic.php?t=417272