Dynasty trade help, your opinion

[pjalst]

5X5 Roto Dynasty with contracts.

The Offer:
he sends
Lincecum $10 3yrs
Granderson$1 3yrs
Zobrist $20 1yr

for my

Ethier $4 4yrs
Hanson $3 2yrs with $10 3yr option after the contract expires.

He also takes on some dead weight players to make the salary exchange even.

MY ROSTER
C Miguel Montero
1B Adrián González
2B Brian Roberts
3B Michael Young
SS Erick Aybar
OF Jayson Werth
OF Andre Ethier
OF Austin Jackson
Util Clint Barmes
Util Carlos Quentin
BN Bobby Abreu

SP CC Sabathia
SP Tommy Hanson
SP Carl Pavano
RP Trevor Hoffman
RP Matt Capps
P Matt Thornton
P Joaquín Benoit
P Matt Belisle
BN Barry Zito
BN Johnny Cueto
BN Jeff Niemann
BN Francisco Liriano
BN James Shields
DL Jordan Zimmermann

[bigoz89]

I think I would rather have 4 years of Ethier and 3 of Hanson at very reasonable rates than 3 years of Lince and 3 of Granderson. I am fearful of Lince breaking down at some point over the next couple years but that is just me.

Thanks for the help on mine.

[MaudDib]

The deal seems pretty fair. I think it depends on what you think Linc will do over the life of that contract compared to what Hanson will do. I don't like Zobrist at $20 so I would think about leaving him out of the deal unless he is part of the reason this deal is being done.

[APAP]

Zobrist at 20 is way too much. Id hang onto Ethier and Hanson at their prices and years.

[fly_high]

I agree. Zobrist at 20 is steep. I'd hold