Big Trade: Cano & Napoli for Greinke & Posada

[StrongBad]

Hi all, I am in a Yahoo 10 team Roto league. One team will receive Greinke and Posada. The other will get Cano and M. Napoli. Before I say which team I'm on, I wanted to see if anyone can view this and determine who wins out. Both teams lineups are posted below. Thanks in advance and WHIR.

The categories are for Hitters: R's, H's, HR's, RBI's, SB's, AVG., OPS

For Pitchers they are: IP's, W's, CG's, Sv's, K's, WHIP, ERA

Team A: Team B:

C: B. Posey C: M. Napoli
1B: M. Cabrera 1B: M. Teixiera
2B: D. Uggla 2B: R. Cano
SS: E. Andrus SS: D. Jeter
3B: A. Ramirez 3B: D. Wright
OF: R. Braun, M. Holliday, J Hamilton OF: C. Hart, B. Abreu, C. Gonzalez
Util: A. Dunn Util: M. Ordonez
Bench: J. Werth, M. Reynolds, J. Posada Bench: M. Montero, C. Figgins, H. Pence,

SP's: J. Verlander, Z. Greinke, M. Scherzer SP's: C. Carpenter, C. Hamels, C. Kershaw
Strasburg, U. Jiminez, J. Niemann C. Billingsley, P. Hughes

RP: B. Wagner, J. Axford, J. Rauch, K. Gregg RP: M. Lindstrom, B. Lidge, B. Jenks, H. Street, A. Simon
Bench/DL: B. Anderson DL: P. Polanco

[Padres Fan]

I hate these, I won't tell you what team I am on questions, but whoever has Grienke needs to hold still and move Reynolds for a semi decent 2B, as the trade weakens one pitching and over crowds the offense.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=416823

[StrongBad]

Fair enough. I am team A and for some reason the post came out looking bad. This trade will make it impossible for me to lose offensively. Do you really think I should stand pat when many argee Cano will be a top 10 for a long time...

[sha]

i like the side that gets Cano and Napoli. Cano is a stud and Grienke's team is too bad.

[Tom Emanski AllStars]

cano / napoli side

[RotoChamp]

Cano and Napoli and it isn't even close.

[StrongBad]

I want to thank everybody for the help. I chose to make the trade and will receive Cano and Napoli. My team is already in first.

To offset the loss of Greinke, I just picked up E. Volquez.

Let me know if you need help.