Reynolds for Cordero? WHIR always!!

[hartmtown]

I'm first in my league but always looking to improve. The guy who owns Reynolds is looking to give up on him and needs a closer. I have 4 right now, with Gonzalez coming back soon for the O's. I offered originally Glaus and Capps for Reynolds (since it sounds like Capps might be traded), but he wants Cordero instead.

So, I give: Cordero, Glaus
I get: Reynolds

What do you think? Capps still might be traded, but I could pick up Storen as insurance or use Gonzalez. I picked up Glaus of the WW a few weeks back so I'm not losing much with him. The only question in my mind is whether I really NEED Reynolds. I figured I could use him as a UTIL player along with Dunn and Ortiz, or to sub Zimmerman at 3rd. I'm leaning toward accepting but I thought I'd get some input.

Standard yahoo 5x5 H2H league. I'd consider a counter-offer to include one of his lesser OFers, but I need to be careful not to try patience too much. I've traded more than 12 times already in this league and have drawn heat for it. All thoughts are appreciated -- leave a link with yours.

My roster:

C - Santana
1B - AGonz
2B - Weeks, SRod, Utley (DL)
3B - Zimmerman
SS - Jeter
OF - Crawford, Rios, Ethier, Granderson
Util - Ortiz, Dunn, Glaus

SP - Felix, Lester, Verlander, Gallardo (DL), Garza, Romero, Marcum (DL), De La Rosa, Niese, Bumgarner, Bedard (DL)
RP - Soriano, Street, Cordero, Capps, M. Gonzalez (DL)

His roster:

C - Posey, Buck
1B - Youkilis, Swisher
2B - Zobrist
3B - Reynolds, Fox
SS - A. Gonzalez
OF - Hunter, Byrd, Holliday, Guillen, Gardner, Bourn, Willingham, Ludwick (DL), Manny (DL)

SP - Ubaldo, Weaver, Lowe, Pineiro, Burnett, Gorzelanny, Buchholz (DL), Moyer, Dickey
RP - Valverde, Gregg

[hartmtown]

I should say I've also sent a couple of other offers.

I give: Capps
I get: Michael Young

or

I give: Capps
I get: Cain

Would either of these deals be better for me? Both are less likely, I think, especially the second.