A. Dunn or A. Gonzalez for A. Wainwright ?

[ucf1956]

I'm in a 7 team - Keeper League (4 Keepers)

I have been offered Wainwright for Dunn or Gonzalez

My potential keepers are:

Halladay
Dunn
Howard
Gonzalez
Bruce
Rollins

Would you make the deal? Is Wainwright good enough to keep from this list?

[daswah]

Wainwright is a legit top ten pitcher...maybe top 5 in NL.

But then...I tend to under value my pitching because elite bats play everyday.

[BG77]

I would deal for him and give Dunn. I definitely think he could be a keeper for you next yr with Roy, Adrian (assuming its not Alex), and Howard.

[Goatrider]

As a Dunn owner and a Cub fan, I'd do it in a second. Dunn's value is so high at the moment and the Cardinals real ace, Wainwright, is a super stud who's only getting better as he approaches his prime. I rather have Wainwright than Lincecum because he won't nick himself up with a stupid delivery. Wainwright is a keeper.

[petert]

give up DUNN an do not look back!

viewtopic.php?t=416682

[hanny2042]

I would deal for him and give Dunn. I definitely think he could be a keeper for you next yr with Roy, Adrian (assuming its not Alex), and Howard.

[chowder]

I wouldn't trade you Wainwright for either of those, but it never hurts to try with Dunn.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=416657