Do I keep M. LaPorta, J. Smoak or C. Davis?

[sjguzin]

Who would you keep? When Ryan Ludwick comes back, should I keep Chris Davis, Justin Smoak or Matt Laporta as my CI? Is there anyone else on my team you would drop for either of those guys?

C- B. Molina
C- M. Montero
1B- A. Gonzalez
2B- C. McGehee
SS- T. Tulowitzki (A. Escobar)
3B- A. Rodriguez
MI- J. Reyes
CI- C. Davis (J. Smoak)
OF- N. Markakis
OF- R. Ibanez
OF- C. Quentin
OF- Dernard Span
OF- Jay Bruce
DH- R. Ludwick (M. LaPorta)

P- J. Santana
P- J. Vazquez
P- M. Cain
P- B. Cecil
P- S. Marcum (J. Chacin)
P- M. Scherzer
P- B. Morrow
RP- J. Axford
RP- O. Dotel

[casem2k2]

I would 100% keep Laporta

[joshc]

Keep LaPorta or Smoak. I think LaPorta will maintain a higher avg, but Smoak has higher upside and has been pretty unlucky. That said, in Seattle his power goes down a bit, so I would lean toward LaPorta.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=416547

[petert]

i like Davis...i think this is do or die for him and i think pressure is off him now with smoak all gone.
Also, Ibenez is a dud this year so maybe that is the answer too if you want to keep both LaPaorta and Davis.

bye bye smoak...he will not do anything this year.

viewtopic.php?t=416541