Quentin vs. Fielder? Need help with major trade!! WHIR*

[oldschool5]

Hey guys need some help as I'm in negotiations on a game changing trade happening right now! I play in a head to head 14 team dynasty keeper league. Salaries based on typical $260 cap and minors roll over for free.
I have been offered a deal that intrigues me and I need your input. I'm currently in 2nd place and won the league last year. This year has been a struggle. I'll list my line up below.

The offer is his Carlos Quentin ($13), Cole Hamels ($30) and Ryan Dempster ($8) or insteand of dempster Brett Cecil ($3)

for me Prince Fielder ($49), Clayton Richard ($3) and Bud norris ($1)

Please help guys really torn on this one. WHIR!!!

C Buster Posey $6
1b Miguel Cabrera $54
2b Utley $50 injury replacement Clint barnes
3b Longoria $16
ss alcides escobar $1
OF Hamilton $25
OF Austin Jackson $1
OF Choo $6 injury replacement Soriano
DH ARod $60
DH Fielder

Sp Lester, Latos, Lackey, Matuzs, Richard, hunter, brett anderson,norris, kennedy
RP Valverde, broxton, bell, greggorson, perez, bard

Minors:Arrieta, casey kelley, jacob turner, matt moore, Jesus montero, Fmart, Hosmer,michael taylor

[oldschool5]

He just upped his offer as I havent pulled the trigger.

now it is is
quentin, hamels, vazquez

for

fielder, richard and norris

What do you guys think? This signifigantly upgrades my pitching although i hate giving up fielder.

Thoughts? Need to make a decision by lunch.

[plapre3]

As much as I'd hate to give up Prince (I think he's in for a big 2nd half), I think you have to pull the trigger on this new offer. Quentin can do well to replace a good portion of Prince's lost offense and your offense is very strong to begin with. If Q cools down a bit down the stretch, you'll have Utley coming back and providing a nice offensive boost anyway.

As currently constructed, you really need help with your starting pitching, especially since Latos will have his innings limited. Hamels and Vazquez will instantly become your 2nd and 3rd best starters in terms of overall value for the rest of the year. Latos may be better and Brett Anderson is a beast, but they won't put up the same kind of innings and have the same kind of impact on your stats. I actually like Richard and Norris, but they are WW fodder for a team as strong as yours

Very nice deal for you... good thing the board didn't respond right away or the other guy might not have thought you were playing hardball and caved.

Please help:
viewtopic.php?t=416510