Buster Posey or Carlos Santana??? WHIR

[s11mike]

Need 1 for the rest of the season. Non keeper league, standard espn scoring. WHIR.

[RDD15]

I prefer Posey. More mature hitter at this point IMO.

[footballisbetter.com]

I very slightly prefer Posey also. Better lineup and he play's first occasionaly.

[shannon]

I'm going to go against the grain here, despite Posey's big night. I think it's very close, but I slightly prefer Santana

Please help
viewtopic.php?t=416360

[JonSamuelson]

It's closer than I wanted to admit when I saw this question (being a Santana owner), but I still think I'd go with Santana. I just trust his ability to hit for average/power more than I do with Posey, but again I admit it's closer than I initially thought. Santana is walking more (a lot more), and he's shown that patience all throughout the minors also. He's shown better power so far, despite Posey's monster performance the last few days, and he showed that power in the minor leagues also. I just think Santana's the guy. If it were a keeper league, perhaps I'd go with Posey because he's a couple of years younger, but let's be honest 24 v. 23 doesn't mean anything in Fantasy.