Trading Josh Hamilton?

[Dren_man]

12 team, H2H, 6X6-non-keeper.
I was thinking about My Hamilton and a SP(Kennedy) for his Granderson and either Josh Johnson or Oswalt? Help Me out with a trade proposal!! Thanks,
Me:
B.Molina,Snyder
Miggy-Stewart-Arod-Furcal
Kinsler-Glaus
Hamilton-Pence-Upton-Upton-A.Jackson-U-Huff
P-Gallardo,Nolasco,Matuz,Scherzer,Bucholz,Kennedy,Bedard,Broxton and Jenks.
Him:
Mauer,Jaso
Votto-Barmes-Reynolds-Tejada
Pennington-Ike Davis
Granderson-Borbon-Markaikis-Patterson-Ross-U-Matsui
P-Josh Johnson,Osawalt,Pelfrey,Bonderman,Lackey,Dempster,Takahasni,M.Rivera,Wolf
DL-Chase Utley!!

[RotoChamp]

Hamilton and Kennedy for Johnson and Granderson seems fair, but I wouldn't do the same trade for Oswalt. Hamilton's stock has never been higher, so keep that in mind.

[Dren_man]

Your thoughts on this:
My Hamilton, BJ Upton, Matusz or Kennedy.
For His Markakis, Granderson and Josh Johnson???? Thanks,

[RotoChamp]

Not a big fan of that one. You would be downgrading two OF to upgrade one SP. Why not Hamilton and Kennedy for Granderson and Johnson? If that doesn't work, Hamilton and Kennedy for Markakis and Johnson.

Hope that helps.

[Dren_man]

Anybody else think this is good trade for Me?....
My Hamilton and Kennedy for His Markakis and Josh Johnson.

[shannon]

How much faith do you have in Markakis? He's been pretty useless so far? I would try to get a better OF in return, unless you believe Markakis is going to turn it around.

[speedy27]

i'd keep Hamilton

[fitz0527]

i'd keep Hamilton

.


I wouldn't trade him for less than a top 10 pick. He's an absolute beast if he stays healthy.

[Jeremiahfira]

How much faith do you have in Markakis? He's been pretty useless so far? I would try to get a better OF in return, unless you believe Markakis is going to turn it around.

Markakis has been turning it around recently, and he does a bit better in the 2nd half...so who knows. Also, even though Granderson's lineup is amazing, he's been really lackluster.