Personal Favorite SP: Builder

[Shakes]

Greg Maddux (+14)

Randy Johnson (+13)

Sandy Koufax (+12)
Nolan Ryan (+12)

Pedro Martinez (+10)

Roy Halladay (+6)

Bob Gibson (+5)
Tim Lincecum (+5)

Curt Schilling (+4)
John Smoltz (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)
Dwight Gooden (+4)

Hideo Nomo (+3)
Satchel Paige (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Tommy Glavine (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)

Phil Niekro(+1)
Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jon Lester (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Warren Spahn (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Clayton Kershaw (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Stephen Strasburg (+1)

[thejusman1]

Greg Maddux (+14)

Randy Johnson (+13)
Sandy Koufax (+13)

Nolan Ryan (+12)

Pedro Martinez (+11)

Roy Halladay (+6)

Bob Gibson (+5)
Tim Lincecum (+5)
Curt Schilling (+5)

John Smoltz (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)
Dwight Gooden (+4)

Hideo Nomo (+3)
Satchel Paige (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Tommy Glavine (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)
Clayton Kershaw (+2)
Jon Lester (+2)

Phil Niekro(+1)
Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Warren Spahn (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Stephen Strasburg (+1)
Derek Lowe (+1)
Josh Beckett (+1)
Bronson Arroyo (+1)

[AquaMan2342]

Some entries were missing I noticed, so I put them back.
Pony League-era AquaMan2342 (+1)

Voting for yourself. How pathetic.

I was so good though

[Nerfherders]

Greg Maddux (+15)

Randy Johnson (+13)
Sandy Koufax (+13)

Nolan Ryan (+12)

Pedro Martinez (+11)

Tim Lincecum (+6)
Roy Halladay (+6)

John Smoltz (+5)
Bob Gibson (+5)
Curt Schilling (+5)

Satchel Paige (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)
Dwight Gooden (+4)

Tom Glavine (+3)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+3)
Hideo Nomo (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Phil Niekro(+2)
Warren Spahn (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)
Clayton Kershaw (+2)
Jon Lester (+2)

Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Stephen Strasburg (+1)
Derek Lowe (+1)
Josh Beckett (+1)
Bronson Arroyo (+1)

[bigken117]

Greg Maddux (+15)

Randy Johnson (+13)
Sandy Koufax (+13)
Nolan Ryan (+13)

Pedro Martinez (+12)

Tim Lincecum (+6)
Roy Halladay (+6)
Bob Gibson (+6)

John Smoltz (+5)
Curt Schilling (+5)
Dwight Gooden (+5)

Satchel Paige (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)


Tom Glavine (+3)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+3)
Hideo Nomo (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)
Jon Lester (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Phil Niekro(+2)
Warren Spahn (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)
Clayton Kershaw (+2)
Stephen Strasburg (+2)


Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Derek Lowe (+1)
Josh Beckett (+1)
Bronson Arroyo (+1)
Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd (+1)
Luis Tiant (+1)

[biesbol]

do I get bonus points for picking 7 of the top 9 with the #2 post??

[mweir145]

It's notable to me that arguably the greatest pitcher of all time in Clemens hasn't made this list. Guess he never made many fans in his four cities.

Greg Maddux (+15)

Randy Johnson (+14)

Sandy Koufax (+13)
Nolan Ryan (+13)
Pedro Martinez (+13)

Roy Halladay (+7)

Tim Lincecum (+6)
Bob Gibson (+6)

John Smoltz (+5)
Curt Schilling (+5)
Dwight Gooden (+5)

Satchel Paige (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)


Tom Glavine (+3)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+3)
Hideo Nomo (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)
Jon Lester (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Phil Niekro(+2)
Warren Spahn (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)
Clayton Kershaw (+2)
Stephen Strasburg (+2)


Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Derek Lowe (+1)
Josh Beckett (+1)
Bronson Arroyo (+1)
Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd (+1)
Luis Tiant (+1)
CC Sabathia (+1)
Pat Hentgen (+1)
Juan Guzman (+1)
AJ Burnett (+1)
Josh Towers (+1)

[jfg]

It's notable to me that arguably the greatest pitcher of all time in Clemens hasn't made this list. Guess he never made many fans in his four cities.

Wow, I hadn't even noticed that. He was on my shortlist, but didn't make the cut. I think only Cobb tops him as the biggest jerk ever in baseball, but still, like you say, he might be the greatest ever.

[GoodOl'Days]

I still like Clemens because he's going to be as mentally tough and physically capable as any other pitcher out there for my team. Call him the Bonds of pitching, he's a winner, only Pedro & Koufax have been better than him. I didn't pick Pedro because I've seen him get hit too hard in too many important situations, just to much hubris in the end to make the best attributes for a pitcher.

To whoever voted for Vida Blue, you rock.




Greg Maddux (+16)

Sandy Koufax (+14)
Randy Johnson (+14)

Nolan Ryan (+13)
Pedro Martinez (+13)

Roy Halladay (+7)

Tim Lincecum (+6)
Bob Gibson (+6)

John Smoltz (+5)
Curt Schilling (+5)
Dwight Gooden (+5)

Satchel Paige (+4)
Walter Johnson (+4)
Tom Seaver (+4)


Tom Glavine (+3)
Ubaldo Jimenez (+3)
Hideo Nomo (+3)
Dizzy Dean (+3)
Mark Prior (+3)
Johan Santana (+3)
Andy Pettite (+3)
Jose Rijo (+3)
Jon Lester (+3)

Orel Hershiser (+2)
Steve Carlton (+2)
Jose Líma (+2)
Max Scherzer (+2)
Old Hoss Radbourn (+2)
Carl Hubbell (+2)
Phil Niekro(+2)
Warren Spahn (+2)
Cy Young (+2)
Jamie Moyer (+2)
Cliff Lee (+2)
Felix Hernandez (+2)
Jake Peavy (+2)
Brad Radke (+2)
Jack Morris (+2)
Catfish Hunter (+2)
David Cone (+2)
Tim Wakefield (+2)
Clayton Kershaw (+2)
Stephen Strasburg (+2)

Rodger Clemens (+1)
Mike Mussina (+1)
Chris Carpenter (+1)
Adam Wainwright (+1)
Robin Roberts (+1)
Cole Hamels (+1)
Frank Tanana (+1)
Vida Blue (+1)
Dave Stewart (+1)
Bob Feller (+1)
Steve Dalkowski (+1)
Francisco Liriano (+1)
Bret Saberhagen (+1)
Gio Gonzalez (+1)
Mat Latos (+1)
Al Leiter (+1)
Ron Darling (+1)
Lefty Grove (+1)
Mickey Lolich (+1)
Mark Langston (+1)
Jim Palmer (+1)
Jake Arietta (+1)
Barry Zito (+1)
Charlie Hough (+1)
Gaylord Perry (+1)
Juan Marichal (+1)
Woody Williams (+1)
Kenny Rogers (+1)
Orlando Hernandez (+1)
Jimmy Key (+1)
Phil Hughes (+1)
Mike Pelfrey (+1)
Tim Hudson (+1)
Zack Grienke (+1)
Bert Blyleven (+1)
Frank Viola (+1)
Ron Guidry(+1)
Whitey Ford(+1)
Mark Fidrych(+1)
Dennis Martinez (+1)
Bill "Spaceman" Lee (+1)
Pascual Perez (+1)
Steve Avery (+1)
Doug Drabek (+1)
Derek Lowe (+1)
Josh Beckett (+1)
Bronson Arroyo (+1)
Dennis "Oil Can" Boyd (+1)
Luis Tiant (+1)
CC Sabathia (+1)
Pat Hentgen (+1)
Juan Guzman (+1)
AJ Burnett (+1)
Josh Towers (+1)

[AussieDodger]

It's notable to me that arguably the greatest pitcher of all time in Clemens hasn't made this list. Guess he never made many fans in his four cities.

I guess just like some of the other players of his era, the more recent extra-curricular shenanigans have blurred what Clemens was.
You can understand people not wanting to vote for a cowardly paedophile.