If you're competing this year, easily accept it. I'm not sure how many keepers you have each season, but I feel it's even in that regard:
Kemp < healthy Utley (not by much)
Greinke > Gallardo (very close)
Holliday = Reynolds (avg and rbi vs. hr)
It's a fair deal for both sides (for 2011...for 2010, clearly the Kemp side). If you love Kemp, pull the trigger.
3 aces or 2 aces and 1 slugger? viewtopic.php?t=415938