Trade for Andre Ethier?

[italiano]

Was offered 2 separate deals that would give me Andre Ethier - please help.

1. My Boesch, Pence and Danks for his Ethier, Smoak and Leake
2. My Boesch, Pence and Bucholtz for his Ethier, Smoak and Niemann?
3. Stand Pat - my team has won 8 of the last 9 weeks despite mediocre pitching.

My team:
c. Suzuki, 1b. Votto, 2b. Lopez, 3b. Beltre, ss. Rollins, of: Carlos Lee, Hunter Pence, Brennan Boesch, Util: Jay Bruce, Adam Dunn, Jason Kubel
Bench: Stephen Drew, Alexei Ramirez, Gordon Beckham, Ike Davis
Pitching: Jaime Garcia, Rickey Romero, Danks, Clay Bucholtz, Ted Lilly, Gio Gonzalez, Tommy Hunter (Rangers), K-Rod, Marmol

[oddmanout7]

Is this a keeper league? If it is, I really like the 1st deal.

The 2nd deal isn't too bad either as you are selling high on Boesch (power and RBIs are real, average will come down), but I like Clay better than Niemann.

[dweenmachine]

I absolutely agree with oddmanout7! The second deal is the better of the two, and Clay is more valuable than Neimann, and even more so if Clay gets traded to a NL team.

Please help with my question. viewtopic.php?t=415395