Butler/CarGo or Liriano/Cruz...WHIR

[khey05]

12 team H2H league with 6x6 cats. (R,HR,RBI,SB,TB,Avg.)(W,K,SV,HLD,ERA,WHIP)

Which side would you rather have for the next three years?

Side A: Billy Butler and Carlos Gonzalez

Side B: Liriano and Nelson Cruz

[fameb]

Tough...I still think Butler can find his power stroke over the next few years as he's fairly young. Once he does he'll be a monster since he's already a solid contact hitter. CarGo I'm not that high on but has potential...Liriano's injury history worries me and Nelson can't seem to stay healthy either but they should both be solid over the next few. I think right now I would lean slightly towards the Liriano side but very slightly.

Please Help
viewtopic.php?t=415344

[DVauthrin]

give me the butler side because hitting tends to be more consistent than pitching year to year.