Should I do this trade??

[amarlls]

So i was thinking of offering my Pedroia and Granderson for his Fielder and Verlander?? Should I do this trade. I have got figgins to fill in at second and then fielder could go to CI or U and then use Cantu as bait to buy more steals somewhere. I just need the pitching. I started by offering grandy for verlander and he said no and then he countered back with fielder for my pedroia. Should I try this trade?

5x5 roto CI MI 5OF 2C

Active Batters
McCann, Brian C ATL
Posey, Buster C SF
Pujols, Albert 1B STL
Pedroia, Dustin 2B BOS
Wright, David 3B NYM
Scutaro, Marco SS BOS
Figgins, Chone 3B SEA
Cantu, Jorge 1B FLA
Cuddyer, Michael RF MIN
Dunn, Adam LF WAS
Granderson, Curtis CF NYY
Hamilton, Josh CF TEX
Pierre, Juan LF CHW
Pena, Carlos 1B TB

Active Pitchers
Broxton, Jonathan RP LA
Corpas, Manuel RP COL
Garza, Matt SP TB
Kershaw, Clayton SP LA
Lidge, Brad RP PHI
Morrow, Brandon SP TOR
Santana, Johan SP NYM
Shields, James SP TB
Zito, Barry SP SF

Reserve Batters
Hawpe, Brad RF COL
Willingham, Josh LF WAS

Reserve Pitchers
Billingsley, Chad SP LA
Dickey, R.A. RP NYM
Jurrjens, Jair SP ATL
Volquez, Edinson SP CIN

[petert]

Fielder and Puljpus and Wright sound mouth watering at the corners!!!!!
Verlander is a Stud on a Stud Team

But the problem is you are trading away two 20-20 guys...are you sure you want to give up that type of balance?

Tough one......

sorry i couldnt be more helpful but when in doubt i stay put.

[amarlls]

anyone else?

[michaelyoung4prez]

I would do it, Prince is typically a second half guy and Verlander would be a very helpful arm for your rotation

[Hit Factory]

I would not make this trade. Fielder is having an "off" year and I never like to give up a big time hitter for a pitcher. Pitchers only help you once every five days, hitters are always going to make an impact. Finding a replacement for Pedroia is going to be extremely tough, Figgins is playing TERRIBLY. If you want a pitcher just go for a 1-1 deal.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=415184

[LloydChristmas]

I'm bearish on both Pedoria and Granderson and bullish on both Fielder and Verlander. Given appropriate replacement (which you may or may not have in Figgings), I think this will be beneficial from here out.

[amarlls]

Dang it im getting total mixed signals here on this trade. I dont know what to do. Anyone else got some advice??

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd go with the Fielder side. Seems like a more than fair price for Fielder who usually is a slow starter but finishes seasons strong. I wouldn't worry about Fielder's power really. Verlander on the side for a fair price also makes this a yes.

[kaiser]

I would want the Fielder side of that deal too. I would be surprised if it is accepted, but if he'll go for it, make the deal.

[DVauthrin]

give me the fielder side of the deal also. you need to be prepared to offer grandy, pedroia and someone like billingsley or garza to get fielder and verlander.