Bay or Granderson

[Kimbos Beard]

Who would you rather hold onto Bay or Granderson?

12 team 5x5 roto redraft. We play 3 OF and I have Abreu, Granderson, Bay, and Cargo. (Pablo is in my Util)

I am looking to swap one of my OF for a SP pitcher perhaps. I have tried to do 2 for 1 packages to upgrade my hitting but it just hasn't worked

My question is who would you rather hold onto for the rest of the year I need HR, and RBI's the most.

My team:

C - Carlos santana
1b - fielder
2b - Phillips
3b - Wright
SS - Alexei ramirez
OF - Bay, Granderson, Cargo,
Util - Pablo
Bnch - Abreu - DL Beltran

SP - Wainwright, cain, Pelfrey, Billingsley, Marcum, Latos, Zambrano
RP - Capps, Aardsma, Rauch

100% WHIR

[petert]

i really think Granderson puts up crazy numbers this month......i like Granderson much better.

viewtopic.php?t=415293

[kaiser]

I agree. Granderson has the better supporting cast, and being a left handed hitter with that short porch in Yankee Stadium is nice. Bay never seems to reach potential (of course, some would say that about Grandy, too.)

[nicks523]

I think im in the same boat as everyone else. I think that Granderson will have a better season from here on out.

[Hit Factory]

I don't like Bay in Citi Field and the Mets lineup is not nearly as potent as the Yankees. I would stick with Granderson.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=415184