Power For Pitching Trade, WHIR

[bondfast12]

Hi guys,

I've been offered a trade.

I receive: Chris Carpenter and Chone Figgins. I give up: Shane Victorino and Mike Napoli.

Right now, for my outfielders I have Boesch, Ordonez, Coghlan, Francoeur, Matsui. For pitching, I have Lester, Weaver, J. Sanchez, Cecil.

What you guys think?

[Shauntell47]

Who's replacing Napoli at catcher?
Is it Rotisserie or H2H you're playing.

I think if you answer these questions, someone could help.

On first look, i'd say nah. Napoli's been better than Figgins, plus you're giving up hitting for pitching. Carpenter is an ace, but Victorino is heading that way too.

Plus, your OF isn't too great, Boesch could cool off at any moment. Your pitching is fine w/ me.

[bondfast12]

Sorry, it's H2H. And my other catcher is Miguel Montero.

[petert]

i dont know much about H2H...but in Roto i wouldnt make that trade. I really like Napoli and Victorino gives you all catagories. but again thats in 5x5...

viewtopic.php?t=415291

[bondfast12]

Yeah, its 5x5.

[kaiser]

Yes, I would make that deal. Chone is overrated for fantasy purposes, and Carpenter will give needed-help to your rotation.

Can you help me with this Granderson for SP deal?
viewtopic.php?t=415297