Trading for pitching

[beefcurtain]

My middle of the pack team needs some pitching. Head to head league with 6x6 categories (losses and OPS). I've been offered:

Oswalt for Butler
Bucholtz for Butler

Butler plays in my utility spot. If I trade him, I'll likely start Garret Jones, Bret Gardner or Delmon Young in his place.

Should I take either trade? If so, which one?

Leave a link and I'll help in return. Thanks.

[Shauntell47]

If Oswalt gets traded, it's a no-brainer. That's really all it comes down too, Buchholz will get a ton of run support, has the talent, but is still young, whereas Oswalt is a proven ace.

I'd say both of those trades are good if you need pitching.


Help w/ mine? viewtopic.php?t=415233

[beefcurtain]

bump

[DVauthrin]

considering you count losses i'd take the buchholz offer. it could be another month before oswalt is traded and buchholz is no slouch himself. plus if it's a keeper league i'd rather have clay anyways.